There are many opinions on how you should give birth.
"Go natural! You will feel empowered and you will recover faster!"
"Get the drugs! No pain is awesome."
Well, as of this summer, I have experienced both routes, and...
I'm still unsure which way is better.
Birth #1
My first birthing experience was like a rollercoaster. First of all, I was living overseas in Taiwan. The baby came early - my water broke in the middle of the night - and so I was unprepared and anxious. My husband and I took the No. 1 bus to TaoYuan Hospital. It felt surreal. I was walking among the people in our street, watching them buy their morning vegetables. I boarded a crowded bus and watched school children in their uniforms riding to school. Everyone was hurrying on with their daily life, but I was off to have a baby.
When we got to my hospital room, I was greeted by the screams of a woman next door to me. She was either in the middle of labor or being mauled by a bear. It did not help to put me at ease. The nurses waited to see if I'd start contractions naturally, but I didn't, so they gave me Pitocin. All this time, I kept on asking, "When will I get my epidural? Is it time to get my epidural?" The nurses smiled and kept telling me to wait.
I waited and waited.
"It's hot!" I kept telling my husband. "Can you turn up the air?"
My husband went to talk to the nurse, and she came and told me the room was actually quite comfortable and the only reason I felt so hot was because I was in labor. I remember thinking very bad things about that nurse.
Let's skip to the good part - they came in and checked dilation. "Good news! You are almost completely dilated. Too late for an epidural. You will have your baby soon." I waited for the good part of that news. The nurse added, "An epidural is expensive anyway. It's 6000 NT ($200 U.S.), this way, you save money." I didn't have much time to think about money, as I was currently trying to rip the railings of my hospital bed off in pain.
I think when you are in so much pain, your mind sort of goes crazy. That happened to me. When the doctor was giving me instructions on how to push, I remembered turning towards my husband for translation. I speak Chinese, but when I was in labor I apparently did not.
When I finally gave birth to my 7 lb, full head of hair, red-skinned daughter,
I felt elated. Not only was I happy because I had my baby, I was happy because I felt I had escaped death. The lights in the ceiling seemed especially shiny, everyone seemed like my best friend - even the money-conscious nurse. When I saw Rose the next morning, I couldn't believe it. It was like waking up from a dream and there in front of you was the thing that was in your dream.

Was going natural empowering? Yes! Would I do it again? ... hmmm.
Birth #2
I decided to have baby #2 by elective induction, so I basically had an appointment to go to the hospital and have my baby. My husband and I woke up to a 6:00 a.m. alarm, made last minute packing adjustments, and shuffled off to the car. As we drove against a slowly brightening sky, everything seemed so calm. My husband and I talked and joked.
When we settled into my hospital room, I got stuck with my IV right away. I blinked back tears, because I'm afraid of needles, but that was the most pain I felt the whole day. Then a systematic order of events followed:
- Hooked up to Pitocin: 9:00 a.m.
- Breaking of water by long crochet hook: 11:00 a.m.
- A visit from the epidural man: 12:45 p.m.
The epidural felt like someone was funneling cool water into my back. It was very comforting - like I was being embraced by the numbing arms of medicine. After that, I relaxed, watched T.V. It was boring.
When the doctor came to see me, she put on a face mask that was like a windshield for eyes. That worried me. Was it really going to be so messy? Then they told me to push. I was a bit unenthused. "What, now?" I said. I tried pushing a couple times but I felt like I was trying to move a phantom limb.
"It's like you're trying to poop. Just pretend like you are pooping," the nurse advised. I looked around at the four or five attentive faces around me and tried to imagine poop.
In between pushes, my husband held my hand loosely, make a couple of jokes, talked to the nurses and doctor. It was very different from the sweaty, white-knuckled grip he had on my hand last time. I was glad to see he was so calm about everything. He told me, "Because you're calm, I'm calm." The atmosphere in the room was so laid back, I wished that my mom and my daughter were there to witness everything.
When Simon finally made his appearance, he looked fat and covered in white cheese. I had the presence of mind to watch everything they did to him, to notice he peed in the warming bed, to take note of his loud cry, to gawk at his weird umbilical cord (it looked like a swollen telephone cord). That was the thing I appreciated most about having no pain,
I had my full mind to take in everything, to remember the small details.
But there was one thing missing. My first birthing experience was full of drama. Sure, there were parts that were like a blur, but in the end I felt euphoria. This time, everything was orderly and systematic. After it was over, I couldn't help but think it was too easy - like, "that was it? Okay."
So whether I would recommend natural or epidural remains unclear. Going natural is terrifying - and I wasn't even brave enough to choose it, it was forced upon me.
But I did it and I'm proud of it. For those wanting an epidural, I can confirm it is so glorious to be numb. In the end, the birth is just one part of your experience of raising a child. The best is yet to come!